| 2026 | TOVAH | Self |
| 2024 | Nhân Loại Sống Còn | Charles York |
| 2022 | The Day the Music Died: The Story of Don McLean's "American Pie" | Self |
| 2021 | Zoey's Extraordinary Christmas | Mitch Clarke |
| One December Night | Mike |
| 2020 | One Night Only: The Best of Broadway | Self |
| Mở Mắt Thấy Hôm Qua | Howard |
| 2019 | Cuộc Gặp Định Mệnh | Ken Scott |
| Stepdaddy | — |
| 2018 | Something in the Air: Making "sex, lies, and videotape" | Self |
| Submission | Len |
| 2017 | Những Bà Mẹ "Ngoan": Giáng Sinh | Hank Mitchell |
| Literally, Right Before Aaron | Orson Schwartzman |
| 2016 | Center Stage: On Pointe | Jonathan Reeves |
| Cruel Intentions | Edward Valmont |
| 2015 | Hello, My Name Is Doris | Willy Williams |
| In a Relationship | The Interviewer (voice) |
| DeTour | Professor Zaring |
| 2012 | Vũ Điệu Đường Phố 4 | Bill Anderson |
| Someday This Pain Will Be Useful to You | Paul Sveck |
| 2010 | Vũ Nữ | Vince Scali |
| Conviction | Barry Scheck |
| GasHole | Narrator (voice) |
| 2009 | Adam | Marty Buchwald |
| The War Boys | Slater |
| 2008 | Center Stage: Turn It Up | Jonathan Reeves |
| 2004 | Broadway's Lost Treasures II | Sky Masterson (segment "Guys & Dolls") |
| 2003 | Comedy Central Roast of Denis Leary | Self |
| The Adventures of Tom Thumb and Thumbelina | The Mole King (voice) |
| How to Deal | Len Martin |
| A Tale of Two Wives | Bill Goodman |
| 2002 | Magic Time: A Tribute to Jack Lemmon | Self |
| Page to Screen: 'The Silence of the Lambs' | Host |
| Ngài Deeds | Chuck Cedar |
| 2001 | Feast of All Saints | Philippe Ferronaire |
| Protection | Ted |
| Perfume | Guido |
| My Favorite Broadway: The Love Songs | Self |
| 2000 | The Last Debate | Tom Chapman |
| American Beauty: Look Closer... | Self |
| Jesus Christ Superstar | First Priest |
| Center Stage | Jonathan Reeves |
| Cupid & Cate | Harry |
| Other Voices | Jordin |
| 1999 | Brotherhood of Murder | Bob Matthews |
| House on Haunted Hill | Donald W. Blackburn, M.D. |
| Vẻ Đẹp Mỹ | Buddy Kane |
| 1998 | Brave New World | Bernard Marx |
| Virtual Obsession | Dr. Joe Messenger |
| Johnny Skidmarks | Johnny Scardino |
| 1997 | The Man Who Knew Too Little | James Ritchie |
| Cafe Society | Jack Kale |
| Path to Paradise: The Untold Story of the World Trade Center Bombing | John Anticev |
| The Trial of Adolf Eichmann | Gideon Hausner (voice) |
| 1996 | To Gillian on Her 37th Birthday | David Lewis |
| Cannes Man | Self |
| Last Dance | John Hayes |
| The Great Irish Famine | narrator |
| 1995 | The Underneath | Michael Chambers |
| Khi Anh Hôn Mê | Peter Callaghan |
| 1994 | Everybody Just Stay Calm | Self |
| Mrs. Parker and the Vicious Circle | Alan Campbell |
| White Mile | Jack Robbins |
| The Hudsucker Proxy | Vic Tenetta |
| 1993 | Short Cuts | Stormy Weathers |
| Mother's Boys | Robert Madigan |
| Malice | Atty. Dennis Riley |
| Watch It | John |
| Luck, Trust & Ketchup: Robert Altman in Carver Country | Self |
| 1992 | Guys and Dolls: Off the Record | Himself / Sky Masterson |
| Bob Roberts | Dan Riley |
| Buying a Landslide | Philip Kautsky |
| The Player | Larry Levy |
| Robert Altman's Players | Self |
| 1991 | The Cabinet of Dr. Ramirez | Matt |
| Late for Dinner | Bob Freeman |
| Milena | Pollak |
| 1990 | Tune in Tomorrow... | Richard Quince |
| Love and Lies | David West |
| 1989 | Tình Dục, Dối Trá Và Băng Video | John Mullany |
| 1988 | I'll Be Home for Christmas | Aaron Copler |
| High Spirits | Brother Tony |
| The Caine Mutiny Court-Martial | Lt. Cmdr. John Challee |
| 1987 | Long Day's Journey Into Night | Edmund Tyrone |
| 1986 | My Little Girl | Kai |
| 1985 | Dreamchild | Jack Dolan |
| 1984 | Terrible Joe Moran | Nick |
| 1982 | Summer Lovers | Michael Pappas |
| 1980 | The Idolmaker | Caesare |
| Skag | John Skagska |